Siding Resources
Cedar Shake vs Shingle: Coursing, Exposure & Cost Explained
Cedar shake and cedar shingle look similar from a distance but are genuinely different products with different costs, textures, and estimating rules — getting the coursing method and undercourse requirements wrong is one of the most common sidewall cedar estimating mistakes. This guide explains exactly what separates them.
Last updated: November 19, 2026
Cedar shake and cedar shingle siding both deliver cedar's natural, authentic wood appearance, but they're produced differently, cost differently, and — critically for anyone estimating a job — follow different coursing and undercourse rules once you get into single vs. double coursing. Getting these rules wrong is one of the most common sidewall cedar estimating mistakes.
This guide explains the real production difference between shake and shingle, breaks down single vs. double coursing in detail, and covers the fire-retardant-treatment question for wildfire-prone areas.
Head-to-Head Comparison
The table below compares cedar shake and cedar shingle across the factors that matter most for a sidewall siding decision.
| Factor | Cedar Shingle | Cedar Shake |
|---|---|---|
| Production method | Fully sawn, both faces | Split (hand or machine); some types sawn on the back only |
| Thickness/texture | Thinner, smooth, uniform | Thicker, rugged, highly textured, natural variation |
| Typical installed cost | $7–$11/sq ft | $10–$14+/sq ft |
| Weight | ~0.7 lb/sq ft | ~1.3 lb/sq ft (roughly double) |
| Common lengths | 16, 18, 24 in | 18, 24 in |
| Pack-size variance | Standard, consistent coverage per bundle | 18 in shakes: 12/12 standard vs. 9/9 at 75% coverage — check your product |
| Appearance | Clean, uniform, more formal | Bold, rustic, dramatic shadow lines |
| Best-fit use | Full wall coverage, budget-conscious authentic wood look | Feature walls, gables, or full coverage where the premium rustic look justifies the cost |
Single Coursing vs. Double Coursing
Coursing method is an independent decision from shake-vs-shingle, and it changes both the exposure per course and the total material needed.
| Factor | Single Coursing | Double Coursing |
|---|---|---|
| Exposure per course | Standard (per CSSB tables, length-dependent) | Significantly greater than single coursing for the same length |
| Layers per course | 1 (face only) | 2 (undercourse + face) |
| Starter (bottom) course | Double layer | Triple layer — 2 undercourse layers + face, per CSSB |
| Undercourse material | Not applicable | Always cedar shingles at the matching undercoursing grade, regardless of face material |
| Total material per sq ft | Lower | Higher — reflects the added undercourse layer |
| Visual effect | Standard, consistent shadow line | Bolder, deeper shadow line from the greater exposure |
Double coursing's bottom (starter) course is a TRIPLE layer — two undercourse layers plus the face layer — not the plain double layer used for every other course above it. This is the single most commonly missed detail when estimating a double-coursed wall.
Common Mistakes
Assuming Double Coursing Just Doubles the Face Material
Double coursing doesn't simply double every course — it specifically requires a TRIPLE-layer starter course at the bottom of the wall (two undercourse layers plus the face layer), not the plain double layer every other course above it gets. Treating the starter the same as every other course undercounts material at the single most water-exposed row on the wall.
Using Leftover Shake as Undercourse Behind a Shake Face
The Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau specifies undercoursing with actual cedar SHINGLES at a dedicated undercoursing grade, independent of the face material — substituting leftover shake pieces (or assuming the undercourse bundle count mirrors the face bundle count 1:1) doesn't match the specified coverage math and can under- or over-order material.
Ignoring the 12/12 vs 9/9 Shake Pack-Size Difference
An 18-inch shake product packed 9/9 covers only about 75% of what a standard 12/12 pack covers for the same bundle count — ordering purely by square-count without checking which pack size your specific product uses can leave a job roughly 25% short of material.
Skipping Fire-Retardant Treatment in a Wildfire-Prone Area
Untreated cedar shake and shingle is combustible and restricted or prohibited in many Wildland-Urban Interface (WUI) wildfire codes — verify your local code's requirement and, where needed, specify fire-retardant-treated material with a current ICC-ES evaluation report before ordering.
Using the Same Nail Count for Exposed and Hidden Courses
The Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau's Sidewall Fastener Guidelines specify 2 nails per piece for exposed face pieces but only 1 nail per piece for hidden undercourse/starter pieces — using a flat 2-nails-everywhere assumption overstates fastener needs for double-coursed walls with a meaningful hidden-layer area.
Standards and References
| Source | What It Covers |
|---|---|
| Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau (CSSB) Wall Manual | The authoritative source for coursing methods, exposure limits, starter-course requirements, undercoursing material specification, and fastener guidelines referenced throughout this guide. |
| ICC-ES evaluation reports for fire-retardant-treated (FRT) shakes/shingles | Code-recognized fire-retardant treatment options for wood sidewall products in wildfire-restricted jurisdictions. |
| Local Wildland-Urban Interface (WUI) building code addenda | Jurisdiction-specific restrictions or treatment requirements for combustible wood siding, which vary significantly by region. |
Final Verdict
Choose cedar shingle for a cleaner, more budget-friendly authentic wood look across a full wall, and cedar shake for a bolder, rustic, dimensional texture where the higher material and labor cost fits the budget — and always get the double-coursing starter course and undercourse material right, regardless of which face material you choose.
- Shake is split and thicker; shingle is sawn and thinner — the production method drives both the look and the cost.
- Double coursing's starter course is a triple layer, not a plain double layer — a frequently missed detail.
- Undercoursing always uses cedar shingles at the matching grade, even behind a shake face.
- Check whether your 18 in shake product is packed 12/12 or 9/9 before ordering by bundle count.
- Verify your local wildfire (WUI) code before specifying untreated cedar in a high-fire-risk area.
- Exposed face pieces take 2 nails each; hidden undercourse/starter pieces take only 1.
Related calculators
Use these calculators when you need to turn this reference information into project quantities:
- Cedar Shake & Shingle Siding Calculator
Estimate cedar shingle or hand-split shake bundles, corner boards, nails, and cost from your own wall sections, coursing method, and exposure.
Related resources
- Siding Material Comparison Guide: Cost, Lifespan & Climate Fit
Complete comparison of eight exterior siding materials — vinyl, fiber cement, wood/engineered wood, stucco, brick/stone veneer, EIFS, metal panel, and cedar shake/shingle — covering installed cost, lifespan, maintenance, weight, and fire resistance.
- Vinyl vs Fiber Cement vs Wood Siding: Which Is Best
Head-to-head comparison of vinyl, fiber cement, and wood/engineered wood siding covering installed cost, lifespan, maintenance, weight, fire resistance, and DIY feasibility — with a scenario table and worked cost example.