Question 1

What's the fundamental difference between concrete pavers and natural flagstone?

Accepted Answer

Concrete pavers are manufactured, uniform units — commonly available in 40mm (1.6 in, thin/pedestrian-only) and 60mm (2.4 in, standard) thicknesses — that interlock or fit together in a repeating pattern with narrow, consistent joints, commonly 1/8 to 3/8 in wide. Natural flagstone is quarried stone (bluestone, sandstone, limestone/travertine, or a generic mixed flagstone) with irregular shapes, variable thickness, and wider, less uniform joints, commonly 1/2 to 1.5 in, since no two pieces are identical and the layout has to be fitted like a puzzle rather than a repeating grid.

Question 2

Which material costs less overall?

Accepted Answer

Concrete pavers are typically cheaper on both material and labor — the material itself usually costs less per square foot than natural stone, and because units are uniform and often interlocking, installation goes faster with less specialized skill required. Natural flagstone commands a premium both for the material (quarried stone, especially bluestone, costs more than manufactured concrete) and for labor, since fitting irregular pieces together with even, consistent joints takes considerably more time and stone-cutting skill than laying a repeating paver pattern.

Question 3

Does flagstone thickness vary by type, and does it matter for installation?

Accepted Answer

Yes — flagstone is typically specified in 1, 1.5, or 2 in thickness, with thinner stone reserved for flat, uniform pieces and 2 in used for thick or noticeably uneven stone backs, since a thicker stone tolerates more variation in its underside without rocking once set. This variability is exactly why flagstone's bedding layer (typically 1-1.5 in of sand, deeper than a paver's standard 1 in bedding) has more room built in — to accommodate stone that isn't perfectly flat on the bottom, something uniform concrete pavers never need to compensate for.

Question 4

How does density and weight compare between paver and flagstone materials?

Accepted Answer

Natural flagstone varies by stone type — generic/mixed flagstone runs around 150 lb per cu ft, bluestone the densest common option at roughly 160 lb per cu ft, sandstone the lightest at roughly 145 lb per cu ft, and limestone/travertine around 155 lb per cu ft. Concrete pavers are manufactured to a consistent density regardless of source, which is one reason paver quantity and weight are far more predictable to estimate than flagstone, where the same square footage of different stone types can weigh noticeably different amounts.

Question 5

Which material gives a more uniform, formal look versus a natural, organic look?

Accepted Answer

Concrete pavers give a clean, repeating, uniform appearance well suited to modern or formal patio designs, and they come in a wide range of manufactured colors, textures, and shapes engineered for a consistent look across the whole installation. Natural flagstone gives an organic, one-of-a-kind appearance where no two installations look identical, favored for naturalistic garden designs, rustic aesthetics, or matching existing natural stone elements on a property — a look concrete pavers can approximate but not truly replicate.

Question 6

Are joint widths interchangeable between the two materials?

Accepted Answer

No — concrete pavers use narrow joints (1/8 to 3/8 in) filled with polymeric sand designed for a tight, interlocking fit between uniform edges, while flagstone uses noticeably wider joints (1/2 to 1.5 in) simply because irregular stone edges can't be cut or fitted tightly enough for a paver-style narrow joint. Wider flagstone joints are sometimes planted with low-growing groundcover (like creeping thyme) rather than filled with sand or mortar, an aesthetic option that doesn't apply to tight paver joints.

Question 7

Can I mix concrete pavers and flagstone in the same patio?

Accepted Answer

It's uncommon and generally not recommended as a primary surface mix, since the two materials have different thicknesses, joint styles, and bedding requirements that complicate a consistent, level installation across both. It's more typical to see one material used as a border or accent against the other (for example, a paver field with a flagstone border, or vice versa) as a deliberate design choice, rather than randomly interspersing both across the whole surface.

Factor	Concrete Pavers	Natural Flagstone
Uniformity	Uniform, manufactured shapes and thickness	Irregular, natural variation in shape and thickness
Common thickness	40mm (1.6 in) or 60mm (2.4 in)	1 in, 1.5 in, or 2 in depending on stone flatness
Typical joint width	1/8-3/8 in (narrow, interlocking)	1/2-1.5 in (wide, irregular fit)
Bedding sand depth	~1 in (standard)	~1-1.5 in (deeper, for uneven undersides)
Density	Consistent, manufacturer-specified	Varies by stone type: 145-160 lb/cu ft
Relative material cost	Lower	Higher — quarried natural stone commands a premium
Installation labor	Faster — uniform units, often interlocking	Slower — irregular pieces fitted like a puzzle
Appearance	Clean, uniform, formal or modern	Organic, one-of-a-kind, rustic or naturalistic

Material	Formula / Substitution	Result
Concrete paver volume (60mm / 2.36 in thick)	200 sq ft × (2.36 ÷ 12) ft	≈39.3 cu ft
Concrete paver weight (typical concrete density, ~145 lb/cu ft)	39.3 × 145	≈5,700 lb
Flagstone volume (1.5 in thick)	200 sq ft × (1.5 ÷ 12) ft	25 cu ft
Limestone/travertine flagstone weight	25 × 155	≈3,875 lb
Bluestone flagstone weight (densest common option)	25 × 160	≈4,000 lb
Sandstone flagstone weight (lightest common option)	25 × 145	≈3,625 lb

Concrete Pavers vs Natural Flagstone: Which Patio Material Is Best

Head-to-Head Comparison

Worked Example — Weight by Flagstone Type

Example — Material Weight for a 200 Sq Ft Patio, Each Material at Its Own Standard Thickness

Common Mistakes

Assuming Flagstone Installs as Fast as Pavers

Using a Standard 1 In Bedding Depth for Thick or Uneven Flagstone

Not Accounting for Stone Type When Estimating Weight or Cost

Filling Wide Flagstone Joints With the Same Polymeric Sand Used for Pavers

Final Verdict

Related calculators

Related resources

FAQ